Hey there,
Yeah, I've heard of Camelot, they were on (the commercialized) BOTY, weren't they?
I checked out the FAQ on the website of the book, and I must say that I'm a bit disappointed.
The arguments against protein are exactly the ones that have been proven to be wrong, like acidity, etc.
He also claims that "fat is fat" and all of the fat has the same effect on the body, which, if you have done some research on the different kinds of fats, you will know it's not true.
It's funny when he talks about Atkins diet which we know isn't funny - it's main benefit is rapid fat loss, not maximum health, far from it, being in ketosis for long periods of time can be very dangerous.
He also talks about herbs and spices having no nutritional value, which is incorrect as well, and if you have done some research on the spices like cinnamon, chilli, etc., you will see that they have a lot of positive health effects. Also, it doesn't quite go in line with years of Chinese medicine.
And, again, consuming a lot of fructose will result in glycation, irrelevant of whether you've eaten any fats or not :|.
Anyway, there are a lot of different nutrition plans out there, and it's hard to say which one is best for someone. I don't think that there's an ultimate best diet for everyone out there as it really depends on their goals, etc.
In this thread, we're talking about productivity. Will the nutrition plan I recommend help you become more productive? Definitely. Is it optimal for everyone? Probably not. But neither will probably any other one.
A person who is used to eating crap will benefit greatly from removing the junk food, sweets, snacks and processed food such as sausages from their diets. Once you do that, it is really up to every individual which balance of nutrient would work for him.
And I am not promoting Paleo diet. I do usually say it's a good starting point to develop your own plan because it is made of unprocessed, raw foods. And if you start from there, you really can't go wrong. I also sometimes link paleo diet recipes because they are usually applicable to a wide range of other nutrition plans. I still don't like that some Paleo dieticians recommend sausages, some prohibit heating meat, and that some avoid dairy. But as I already said, that's personal preference.
What is interesting though is that the people who are on Paleo + Cross fit (these usually go hand in hand) in general seem way fitter than the ones on this 80/10/10 diet. Actually, it's hard to find some visible results of this diet, apart from testimonials about how people feel after a couple of months (which are similar to other diets as well).
The thing that irritates me the most though is the forum of 80/10/10. Whenever someone has some trouble or becomes ill, they either recommend fasting at one of their facilities or to have a private consultation with the author of the book, which costs $75 for him just to review their questionnaire and reply them via an e-mail. If this guy desperately wanted to help people, he would actually reply on his own forum. But it seems that he is more busy writing and selling 20 books and making seminars :|.
To sum up, it might be a good diet for some people. It might be a good diet for many people. But you can't claim that it's the optimal diet because other diets have too little carbs... It all depends on one's goals. And since we all have different goals, one solution won't fit everyone.
It's good to have different points of views and to research different diets and read different books as we can always learn something from them. But saying that one thing is an absolute truth without even trying to understand the other points of view won't get you optimal results in any area of life.
I've heard of the China study and am planning on reading it as well (it's on my books list). It's a shame that this 80/10/10 book isn't available on kindle, I hope that I can at least buy it as a pdf and transfer it to my kindle. The book itself is pretty expensive though, I've heard that it used to be like $100... isn't that a bit much for a book on nutrition if the author's main motive is to help people :|?
Now, I am really wondering, which diet were you on before that you've had such bad results on?
I've personally tried different things out and sticked with the thing that works best for me. And it has worked amazingly for about 2 years already. So if something works great, it's usually not all that wise to change it.
My current nutrition plan meets my expectations - I have tons of energy, focus, concentration, very few injuries and great regeneration, which is all that I require. If your goals are met, there isn't much of a reason to change and not many people will be able to convince you to change something.
However, despite that, I always try to understand the different theories, and I always try to apply at least some parts of them and see how they work. If they work, I keep them, if they don't, I don't :).
For example, the diet that you recommend would mean going from a lot of protein a day to very little protein a day. Now, I've had the experience in the past that if I ate too little protein, my regeneration would be crappy, my sports performance wouldn't be the best and I would be hungry a lot. Injuries would also increase. Since you know how unnatural and joint damaging bboying is, I can't take the risk to withdraw the protein, as I could risk a serious injury if I look at my past experience.
I sure hope that your diet will work for you in the long run, but you'll see for yourself with time :).
I do recommend looking at the book "convict conditioning" though, it'll help you strengthen your joints ;).
-SF