I had a long break at work today and started thinking about why some players make so much more than others even though they often have most of the same skillsets/aptitudes and are both intelligent individuals. This turned into a monster post and I don’t expect anyone to read it all, but I find that writing helps me formulate my own thoughts so here we go:
Being a winning poker player means a lot of things. It means you’ve studied the theoretical aspect of the game and are constantly trying to improve your understanding of how to best exploit every individual opponent. It also means that you are realistic with yourself and are able to pretty accurately assess whether on not you’re playing in a +EV game, and also that there are no better EV games out there (good table selection). It also means that you’ve developed good discipline and have established a bankroll management that works for you. In other words, you’re never playing a game that you can’t afford to lose on the short term. Last, and most important of all as far as I’m concerned, is that you play as close to you’re best game possible every minute that you’re sitting at the table.
Obviously I’m not perfect in any of these areas, but I’d say I’ve put a lot of effort into all of them in order to improve myself over the past year. I believe that on the whole I have really improved a lot (to the point that I’m quite good at) all of the aspects listed above EXCEPT for the last one. As much as I’ve thought about it and worked on it, I think there are big differences in between my A game and my B game so to speak, and that doesn’t even include the rare (but very costly) serious tilting.
I need to put my ego aside and be realistic with myself in admitting that I’m playing my B game way more often than I think and that my B game isn’t half as good as I think. Ego and self-confidence are essential to playing poker because they help you survive variance when things aren’t going your way. On the other hand they can be detrimental to improvement because they block your ability to analyze yourself from an unbiased point of view and realize areas that need improvement. I don’t think it’s a stretch to say that 99% of poker player thinks that they’re better than they actually are. If you ask anyone if they’re a winner in the game their playing they’ll undoubtedly answer yes, but the real answer is probably more like: Yes, when I’m playing my A game. In my opinion the biggest difference between the big winners and the break-even regulars (especially the higher the limit you play) is simply how often they’re on their game, or the difference in quality between their A game and their B game.
I’m going to make a checklist of all the small questions that I should ask myself on a daily basis to improve the quality of my game and make good decisions. It’s making the wrong ‘little’ decision that leads me to tilting or playing B game poker. To achieve a solid winrate it’s not enough to identify that your tilting and stop playing once it’s already started, because you’ve probably already lost way too much!
1) When starting a session, do I feel like playing poker because I want to think about strategy, work through tough spots and improve my game? Or do I want to play poker because I want money. There is a bit of a contraction here because money can definitely be a motivator to learn and improve, but when I’m playing a session it should be out of my head (because I’m so focused on the game itself).
I think that a good way to think about this (Something like this is explained in a Phil Galfond video, so you can thank him!) is to imagine you’re average winrate that you think is achievable when you’re playing well and evaluate if it’s worth playing. Let’s say I’ve lost 1k in my 2 hour morning session, and I now get home from work and have 2 hours to play poker. I don’t really feel like it, but I really want to erase my negative session from this morning, and I know that it’s very possible to do this if I run good. Maybe my winrate with rakeback and everything is between 50-100$/hour. In reality, all I can really hope for is to play the best I can for that 2 hour period and expect to have made on average 100-200$ (just like I hypothetically made in my morning session, even though I lost on the short term). I can’t even imagine the number of times I’ve started a session thinking this. The worst part is that in reality you’re winrate might not even be positive at all (and is almost certainly less than your optimal winrate) when you’re playing with this mindset because it’s hard to play close to you’re A game when you’re thinking about other things.
2) How is this session going to affect my ‘happiness EV’? (This is also from the same Galfond video I think) There are times when I feel like I should play poker for whatever reason, but I’d be much happier doing something else. Not only is it hard to play well when you’re not into it, but if I play a few sessions that I don’t feel like playing, it can result in me taking a week off afterwards or feeling burnt out. This is a life balance thing, and I actually end up playing more if I’m only playing when I feel like it. This is pretty important for me, considering I’m challenging myself to play more than usual for the next few months.
3) When starting a session, am I ready to lose the whole time, but not care because I know that I’m playing to the best of my ability? Or am I conscious that I’m too emotional for whatever reason and should just do something else. Sometimes for no apparent reason, I can tell that swings are going to affect my quality of play because I’m too emotionally involved. Even when I realize this I often either say to myself: fuck it, this is the only 2 hour period I have to play in the next 2 days. Or: I’m mentally tough and I’ll push through it if things aren’t going well. The second point is simply my ego getting in the way and I need to be able to tell in the first 5-10min of a session whether or not I’m playing without emotion.
4) During a session do I feel rushed/stressed/pressured? This sometimes happens when I’m multitabling and is definitely an early sign of either B game play or tilt. Some days I can easily play 8 tables really thinking hard about every spot, whereas other days (if I’m hungover for instance) I can barely think through 4 tables.
5) During a session am I seeing small technical errors in my game that I don’t normally make? Every one in a while I find myself making some weird out of position float, or check/raising a flop for no apparent reason. Although a lot of these little things on their own aren’t so bad, it’s a sign that I’m not playing my best anymore. At this point I need to be either improving my focus or taking a break.
6) During a session do I notice that I’m no longer thinking ahead to later streets and/or just kind of cruising? This happens relatively often, and it’s an obvious sign that it’s break time (even just for 30min or whatever)
7) At the end of a session, did I make mistakes in the big pots that I played? I’m trying to look back on every pot where I end up all in at the end of sessions to see if I think I played them optimally. It’s easy to just call a hand a cooler, or whatever without even really making sure that you couldn’t have folded at some point against your opponents range. I also find that when I win a pot after getting my money in bad (flushdraw vs set is a common scenario) I often completely forget about it, and don’t analyze weather or not there was a better way to play my draw against the entire range of that specific opponent.
8) At the end of a session, did I honestly evaluate myself on questions 1-7 throughout the session? If so then I’m the best I can be!..the other 100% of the time there’s something I need to improve 
I’m going to print this checklist and put it beside my computer. If I can go quickly ask myself these question and honestly answer them then I have no doubt that I’ll improve a lot in the self control department! (I know, I know…easier said than done) This is why I love poker! There are always tones of things you could be doing better so it stays interesting and challenging.
If anyone actually got this far…I’m impressed!..and hopefully you enjoyed ♠_biggrin: