You might laugh it off and call me crazy, you might get angry and think me some sly salesman, you might start talking about some flaw in the logic. There is no flaw. I made $180,000 playing 6max over 2 years when I stopped to work on this. My brother had a poker school. I know what I'm talking about. So if you doubt it, please dont accuse me of being wrong, please dont laugh etc, just explain to me where you think the problem is and I will explain it to you. I think that piece of evidence is solid. So please try to point your problems towards that, if you think I'm mad, please explain why I am the first to realise that at level four we consider what the opponent is pretending to hold.
Hello yadijavadi,
I have over the past few days read a few of the constructive feed back in regards to your book. I personally downloaded it from your link and found that it was not something I was ready to commit a read. Maybe this is due to the way you have dealt with the constructive criticism from fellow pokerstrategists that put me off turning the next page.
I have played poker for 5 years at recreational level. I have had goods times and many bad times, but without the community here would not have carried on. Without sharing my level of understanding and listening to the feedback received by members here, weather it be from a professional player or not I would have failed / given up much earlier on!
I understand that you have put many hours into presenting your view on exploitative theory and the levels of thought and I congratulate you on such a massive task.
But in all reality you yourself have missed the very point of the title of this blog Please Help Me Prove Something Insane...
People are trying to help you prove something insane by constructively helping point areas of your work that need adjusting. You shouldn't post in forums and expect everyone to agree with you and especially if you can't take the criticism / constructive feedback on board. How will we ever learn in life if not from other peoples feedback / help!!
Have you taken the time to look at the wealth of information on this site? You will be surprised how much information there is that covers these points you talk about. It may be from a different angle to yours, but ultimately it is the same.
Originally posted by la55i
Hmm this thread again.. You posted one 6 months ago too.
I didn't read this thread but if I remember correctly, you were very intelligent and your thinking was so brilliant that we mere mortals couldn't understand it. I'm looking forward to reading that book. Hopefully it will give me some clarity.
Clearly from reading La55i response earlier on and other comments throughout this thread you have rubbed up people in the wrong way when ever posting your thoughts and the way you deal with feedback.
I believe that if you adjust your personal approach in future on how you deal with criticism you can, and will create better texts in the future by learning from your readers views / opinions and integrating that into the way you approach future work. This is how good books evolve and I can prove this by pointing that you haven't included any acknowledgments in the book! Did your family have patience with you while you wrote your book and were they patient with the amount of time you spent working on it? How about acknowledgments to anyone else who has helped you? Do you see where I am going with this? When I pick up any book the authors all acknowledge the help they have received from other people in creating a great read!!
Finally I am unable to add to this conversation on the professional levels my colleagues can when dealing with the subject but I can say you are wrong in your approach as it comes across to me that you are unable to converse with other people when they point areas they disagree with you on.
I hold with high regard the active members of this community here on the forums and trust their views and opinions as do many beginners / professional players looking to improve their game or even social network / friends. I disagree with rudeness and arrogance, especially from someone who has a history of this kind of behaviour and doesn't learn.
I am saddened that this thread hasn't been a more positive discussion and you haven't tried to engage with the wider community in other areas along with taking on board the constructive thoughts. I hope that what we have constructively said to you, be it positive or not will help you in future when you next approach people for their feedback or reviews of your work. This is a transferable skill that applies to many areas of life not just poker!
For the sake of anti tilt I am going to lock this thread from future comments. If you wish to continue as a active member of the community I expect a better attitude from you. This is your final warning as I am not going to ask for you to be banned.
Good luck at the tables to everyone 
Matt
